The Yankees are set to be the team to beat in 2017 with position players including Gary Sanchez, Aaron Judge, Jorge Mateo, Gleyber Torres, and Tyler Austin all under 25 years old. While the Yankees do not have top-tier pitching prospects, they do have depth with players such as Jordan Montgomery, Dillon Tate, Chance Adams, Justus Sheffield, James Kaprielian, Albert Abreu, and Ian Clarkin with other young arms in the majors already. This is why the Yankees made the wise decision to not pick up a starting pitcher in free agency. It was a thin market so let’s look at why the Yankees made the right decision to pass on certain free agents.
Rich Hill: He wanted a multi-year deal and got that with 3-years for $48 Million with the Dodgers. He is always hurt and with no long-term proven success, he was not worth signing through his age 39 season.
Ivan Nova: Inconsistent and seemed to need a change of scenery. While he was very effective with the Pirates this does not mean it would transition back to the Bronx where Ivan struggled. He could very well have a better career in Pittsburgh than New York (See A.J. Burnett).
Charlie Morton: He pitched only 4 games in 2016, and has not had an ERA under 3.70 since 2013. A player on the downward trend is not worth $14 million per year and the Yankees are better off using Bryan Mitchell or Luis Severino.
I would have like to have seen the Yankees go after Jeremy Hellickson but with him surprisingly taking Phillies qualifying offer, he was off the market. With Masahiro Tanaka, C.C. Sabathia, and Michael Pineda looks to be in the starting rotation, and a bunch of young arms competing for 2 rotation spots, the Yankees were wise to not overpay any of these free agents.
~Gregory Hold